T. A. Frank’s VDARE.com-Style Analysis In VANITY FAIR: Immigration Could Destroy Hillary With White Voters

By Washington Watcher

05/18/2016

T.A. Frank has a pretty good article at Vanity Fair noting that Hillary Clinton’s Open Borders position on immigration will likely push working class whites towards Trump, which could swing the election.

Frank plays around with the numbers and notes

Two examples will suffice, and both were arrived at by using the remarkable Swing-o-Matic from FiveThirtyEight. In the 2012 election, 57 percent of non-college-educated whites showed up to vote, and 62 percent of them voted Republican. So let’s keep turnout the same and play with vote share. If 73 percent of these non-college-educated whites had voted Republican, then, even if 100 percent of Latino voters (as opposed 71 percent) had gone for Obama, Mitt Romney would have won the election. This year, Latino voters will probably show up in larger numbers, inspired by revulsion toward Trump, and black voters may show up in smaller numbers than the ones Barack Obama is believed to have inspired.

So let’s suppose the African-American vote reverts to the 2004 figures: 60 percent turnout, 88 percent Democratic. With a five-point increase in turnout among non-college-educated whites and a 10-point increase (from 62 percent to 72 percent) in the share of their votes, Trump seems to have a secure win. That would remain the case even if Latinos increased voter turnout by 10 points (from 48 to 50 percent) and increased their support for Democrats by nearly 30 points, up to 100 percent. Fundamentally, then, a small percentage of white voters hating Clinton’s stance on immigration could outweigh a large percentage of Hispanic voters liking it. (Emphasis added.)[The One Issue That Could Destroy Hillary Clinton, May 17, 2016]

Sound familiar? In December, I made almost the exact assumptions, using the same FiveThirtyEight Swing-O-Matic feature, and found they could result in a Trump win:

[Trump CAN Win Presidency With White Working Class–Nate Silver (Unintentionally) Says So!, December 13, 2005]

I doubt Frank was stealing my arguments. Trump’s persistent success with the white working class is impossible to ignore. However, to be immodest, it’s one of many examples where VDARE.com has been ahead of the curve.

< Previous

Next >


This is a content archive of VDARE.com, which Letitia James forced off of the Internet using lawfare.